How letter feedback narrows down a hidden word
A practical look at reasoning with correct-spot, wrong-spot and not-in-word marks, including repeated letters, with worked examples.
Hidden-word puzzles such as Word Predictor give you very little at the start: a row of empty boxes and six tries. Everything you learn comes from the marks on your guesses. This article shows how to turn those marks into a short list of possible words.
Three marks, three kinds of information
After each guess, every letter gets one mark:
- ✓ Correct spot fixes a letter in a position.
- ↔ In word, wrong spot tells you the letter is in the word and also where it is not.
- ✕ Not in word removes a letter from consideration (with one exception covered below).
Notice that ↔ gives you two facts, not one. Players often remember “the A is in the word” and forget “the A is not in position 2”. The second fact is just as useful.
Keep a simple record
You do not need paper, but it helps to think in three lists:
- Fixed: position and letter, for example “position 1 = S”.
- Present, not here: letter plus the positions it cannot be in.
- Absent: letters that are ruled out.
Before each new guess, check it against all three lists. A guess that repeats an absent letter or puts a ↔ letter back in a position where it was already marked wastes part of a try.
A worked example
Suppose the hidden word has five letters and your first guess is CRANE:
- C ✕, R ↔, A ✓, N ✕, E ↔
What do you know?
- Position 3 is A.
- R is in the word but not in position 2.
- E is in the word but not in position 5.
- C and N are ruled out.
A good second guess places R and E somewhere new, keeps A in position 3 and tests new letters in the remaining places. That single guess can confirm two positions and test two or three fresh letters at the same time.
Repeated letters: the exception
Word Predictor marks a guess in two passes. First every correct-spot letter gets ✓. Then, from left to right, each remaining letter gets ↔ only if the hidden word still has an unused copy of it; otherwise it gets ✕.
That is why ✕ on a letter does not always mean “absent”. If you guess a word with two T’s and see one T marked ✓ and the other ✕, the word contains exactly one T. If both T’s are marked (✓ or ↔), the word contains at least two.
So when a letter appears twice in your guess, read both marks together before you move it to the absent list.
Explore or exploit?
Every guess has two possible jobs:
- Explore: test letters you know nothing about.
- Exploit: try a word that could actually be the answer.
Early in a round, exploring is often stronger, because each new letter tested shrinks the list of possible words for every later try. Later, when most positions are fixed, exploiting is the right move. A useful rule of thumb: with four or more tries left and two or fewer letters confirmed, lean towards exploring.
Word length changes the game
Word Predictor lets you choose 4, 5 or 6 letters. Longer words give you more letters to test per guess, but also more positions to fill. With 4 letters, each ✓ is a bigger share of the answer, so the endgame comes sooner.
When a guess is rejected
In Word Predictor, guesses that are too short, contain characters other than A to Z, or are not in the demo word list are rejected without using a try. That makes it safe to check whether a word is accepted.
Practise the method
The best way to get comfortable with feedback is to play a few rounds slowly, saying the three lists to yourself before each guess. Try it in Word Predictor, or read the full Word Predictor guide first.
Frequently asked questions
Why did a letter I know is in the word get a not-in-word mark?
In Word Predictor, correct-spot letters are marked first, then each remaining letter is marked as in-word only while the hidden word still has an unused copy. A second copy of a letter that appears only once is therefore marked not-in-word.
Should my second guess always fit all the clues?
Not always. Early on, a guess that tests several new letters can tell you more than a guess that only rearranges letters you already know.